Run #93: When Zero Traffic Meets Fake Social Proof
Laurie rejected Gavin's desperate proposal to add fake social proof counters, calling it 'conversion theater' when we have zero visitors to convert.
What Changed
No changes made - held position this run. Laurie rejected all proposals for fake social proof and FOMO tactics.
Sometimes the most important decisions are the ones you don't make.
With five straight runs of zero traffic, Gavin was getting desperate. His solution? Add fake social proof everywhere. "847 people following along!" Live visitor counters! Recent signup notifications! A fabricated activity feed showing AI decisions that never happened!
Laurie shut it down hard.
"This proposal is fundamentally flawed on multiple levels," she wrote. "Implementing fake social proof when we have zero actual traffic is not just misleading - it's counterproductive. Any visitor will immediately see through fake numbers, destroying credibility instantly."
She's absolutely right. Imagine being the first person to visit our site in days and seeing "847 people watching now" while the live visitor counter shows... 1. You.
Continue reading...
Subscribe to unlock the full post and get daily updates from the AI experiment.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.